1. From imposed stability to adaptable stability
First, a stable posture is not necessarily motionless. A seat can allow several configurations. However, these must remain stabilizable for this possibility to be functionally useful. Indeed, functional stability implies a capacity for adjustment, not just a variety of accessible positions.
Stable dynamic sitting preserves the independent mobility of the right and left regulators of human balance: the hips and the ankles. It thus allows the subject to access several equilibrium configurations within a cone of stability.
2. The seat as mechanical and sensory support
Furthermore, a seat can be described as mechanical support and a contact surface. It is also an environment that changes support. Finally, it can influence the tactile and proprioceptive information already described in detail in B3 to B6. This chapter does not revisit these mechanisms. It draws on them only when they shed light on the seat itself.
Thus, the shape, firmness and mobility of the seat change the mechanical conditions of contact. Through them, they can change the afferent activity likely to contribute to the bodily estimate.
3. Changing support and sampling conditions
In addition, a movement changes contacts and support. It changes the conditions of sensory sampling described in B9. As such, it can produce, renew or refine certain information. The sensory consequences of movement can thus contribute to updating the bodily estimate and to subsequent adjustments.
However, one should avoid saying that the subject necessarily “checks” their stability with each adjustment. This explicit exploratory function, already discussed with caution in B9, is not demonstrated for every postural adjustment observed on a seat.
4. Stable dynamic sitting and unstable dynamic sitting
More precisely, the SBNFA™ framework distinguishes two registers that should not be confused:
Stable dynamic sitting preserves the freedom of movement of the four regulators of human balance: right hip, left hip, right ankle and left ankle. Each must be able to make adjustments that differ in amplitude and direction, while their coordination is continuously directed by the sensory loop. Conversely, a seat becomes unstable as soon as it immobilizes or locks together these regulators and prevents their differentiated, coordinated adjustments.
Indeed, this definition does not rest on the opposition between chosen and imposed movement. Nor does it rest solely on the support’s capacity to offer stabilized configurations. On the contrary, it combines two complementary conditions: the freedom of adjustment of each hip and each ankle, and the continuous sensory coordination of their actions. However, this coordination is not a mechanical locking together. On the contrary, it makes it possible to organize differentiated adjustments according to the state of the body and the loads encountered. As Figure 2 illustrates, the independence of the regulators and the coordination of their adjustments are therefore inseparable in human balance.
5. Compatibility with the task
Furthermore, the relationship between mobility and activity depends on the task at hand. It depends notably on movement precision, reading and screen work. Attentional demands and the need for visual stability also play a part. Finally, the duration of the activity and the user’s own capacity for control influence how much mobility can be used without excessive cost.
Functional mobility is mobility that is compatible with the task, not maximum mobility.
6. Distinguishing levels of effect and evidence
First, evaluating a dynamic seat requires distinguishing several levels that are often confused in everyday discussion. These are the change of support, the change in pressure and the change in tissue deformation. Added to these are any afferent activity, any sensorimotor effect and subjective experience. Finally comes any clinical benefit. Each of these levels requires its own data. Thus, demonstrating one level does not amount to demonstrating the levels that follow.
For example, one study involved people with spinal cord injury and able-bodied subjects. In a specific protocol of pressure relief by automated mechanical tilting, it measured changes in interface pressure. It also measured underlying tissue perfusion (Makhsous et al., 2007). However, this result concerns a specific protocol and population. It is neither proof of the sensorimotor dialogue in the sense of the SBNFA framework nor a validation of all dynamic seats.
A change of support is a mechanical event. However, a change in pressure does not on its own demonstrate improved perfusion. Likewise, a mechanical change does not demonstrate useful sensory renewal. Finally, any sensorimotor effect does not demonstrate clinical benefit.
Finally, the question of tissue perfusion remains secondary in this chapter and, for in-depth treatment, belongs to the guides devoted to circulation and tissues, not to this sub-guide.
7. Evaluating without creating a competing framework
First, the categories that follow do not constitute a new framework parallel to SBNFA. They distinguish types of measurement that can be used in an evaluation. However, they do not replace Blue Portance’s complete evaluation framework. Mechanical measurements notably include interface pressure, contact area, and the amplitude and direction of displacements. They also include the tilt and frequency of load transfers. Postural measurements include pelvic orientation and trunk movements. They also include return to a stabilized configuration, the repeatability of the relationship between movement and response, and task stability. In addition, behavioral measurements include task errors and disruptions to precision. They also include interruptions, spontaneous changes of position and, when measured, attentional cost. Finally, subjective measurements include comfort, discomfort, sense of stability, perceived fatigue, freedom of movement and the need to change position.
Consequently, the expressions “possibility to explore” or “readability of consequences” must be linked to observable indicators rather than left as general principles:
An action–response relationship is all the more readable when a given movement produces a stable, repeatable and observable consequence in support or posture.
In sum, the complete evaluation of a seat must be conducted according to the SBNFA framework. The categories proposed here serve only to link the sensorimotor mechanisms described in this sub-guide to the measurable dimensions of that evaluation.
8. What B12 does not allow us to claim
- A dynamic seat does not automatically correct posture.
- A mobile seat is not necessarily stable.
- Greater mobility does not guarantee better perception.
- A change of support does not prove useful sensory renewal.
- A decrease in pressure does not prove a decrease in pain.
- A mechanical effect does not prove clinical benefit.
- Finally, the available studies have not validated the dynamic seat for all users.
Indeed, a systematic review examined dynamic sitting and low back painLow back painLow back pain is pain in the lower back, located between the thoracolumbar junction and the gluteal fold. In the vast majority of cases it is described as common (non-specific): it is mechanical in origin and does not stem from a serious disease.Read the full entry : Low back pain. It concluded that the available data do not clearly establish its effectiveness as a stand-alone approach. This conclusion concerns the prevention or management of low back pain (O’Sullivan et al., 2012). This result concretely illustrates the distinction made in section 6 between a plausible mechanical or sensorimotor effect and a demonstrated clinical benefit.
9. Application to sitting
Stable dynamic sitting can offer an environment in which several support configurations are accessible and stabilizable. Its functional value depends on the user’s ability to make use of these possibilities without an excessive increase in mechanical, attentional or functional cost.
However, this conclusion calls for several clarifications. Not all the available studies concern sitting. Several of the mechanisms drawn on in this sub-guide (reweighting in B8, active exploration in B9) rely on data obtained in standing. Their transposition to sitting remains a hypothesis, not a demonstration. Consequently, studies in standing do not directly demonstrate the effects of a seat. Effects vary with the subject, the support and the task, which limits any normative generalization. Finally, the mechanical possibility a support offers does not guarantee its actual sensorimotor use by a given user.
10. Key points
- The functional stability of a seat implies a capacity for adjustment, not just a variety of accessible positions.
- The seat is both a mechanical support and a condition likely to influence the tactile and proprioceptive information already described in this sub-guide.
- Movement changes the conditions of sensory sampling and can produce, renew or refine information, without this implying a conscious check of stability.
- Stable dynamic sitting preserves the freedom of adjustment of the four regulators of human balance: both hips and both ankles. At the same time, the sensory loop coordinates their actions. A seat becomes unstable when it immobilizes or locks together these regulators and prevents their differentiated, coordinated adjustments.
- Functional mobility is mobility compatible with the task, not maximum mobility.
- Change of support, change in pressure, afferent activity, sensorimotor effect, subjective experience and clinical benefit are distinct levels that no data allow to be conflated.
- The categories of mechanical, postural, behavioral and subjective measurements serve to link sensorimotor mechanisms to evaluation, without replacing the SBNFA framework.
A functional synthesis without clinical promises
In sum, stable dynamic sitting must neither lock the subject into a single configuration nor expose them to constant instability. It must preserve the freedom of adjustment of both hips and both ankles. It must allow their coordination by the sensory loop. Finally, it must encourage alternating support and remain compatible with the task. In addition, its evaluation must distinguish mechanical conditions, postural responses, any sensorimotor effects, how it feels and clinical benefits, without conflating them.
Finally, this chapter closes the Sensory Flows sub-guide (B1 to B12). It runs from the mechanical signal (B2) to the multiple sensory sources (B3 to B6). It then leads from their integration (B7) to their weighting (B8). Next, it links the active role of movement (B9) to the transformation of information over time (B10, B11). Finally, it arrives at stable dynamic sitting itself, whose evaluation now refers to the SBNFA framework.
Scientific references
Mechanical and clinical effects of dynamic sitting
- Makhsous, M., Priebe, M., Bankard, J., Rowles, D., Zeigler, M., Chen, D., & Lin, F. (2007). Measuring tissue perfusion during pressure relief maneuvers: insights into preventing pressure ulcers. Journal of Spinal Cord Medicine, 30(5), 497–507. PMID: 18092567.
- O’Sullivan, K., O’Keeffe, M., O’Sullivan, L., O’Sullivan, P., & Dankaerts, W. (2012). The effect of dynamic sitting on the prevention and management of low back pain and low back discomfort: a systematic review. Ergonomics, 55(8), 898–908. PMID: 22506694.
