1. Defining proprioception: a multisource construction
Proprioception thus refers to all the afferent information relating to the shape of the body and its configuration. It also provides information on the position and movement of its segments, as well as on the forces it develops. This broad definition covers the senses of position, movement, force, effort and heaviness (Proske & Gandevia, 2012). It relies on populations of afferents located in muscles, tendons, joints and skin. It does not rely on a single receptor or modality.
However, these peripheral afferents must be distinguished from the other sources that contribute to the estimation of body state. Vestibular and visual information takes part in this estimation, as does internal information linked to the motor command itself. These contributions are not, however, proprioceptive afferents in the same way as a muscular or cutaneous afferent. Rather, they are integrated with them to build an overall representation, without strictly being part of them.
Indeed, reducing proprioception to a single organ or type of receptor leads to misleading simplifications. Conversely, none of these sources provides information, on its own, on all the dimensions of proprioception. The position of a joint, the speed of a movement and the intensity of the effort produced do not necessarily rely on the same mechanisms. The following sections will show this.
2. Proprioception and kinesthesia
Moreover, terminological usage varies in the literature. In some frameworks, proprioception broadly refers to information about the configuration, position, movement and mechanical state of the body. This information may or may not give rise to a conscious sensation. Kinesthesia refers more specifically, in these same frameworks, to the conscious perception of the position and movement of body segments (Proske & Gandevia, 2009).
However, this distinction should not be understood as the separation of two independent systems. The same peripheral signals can contribute both to automatic postural corrections, which require no conscious perception, and to a conscious experience of movement when attention is directed to it. The distinction nevertheless remains useful. It avoids confusing the information available for motor control with what the subject actually perceives of it.
3. Neuromuscular spindles
In particular, neuromuscular spindles are sensory receptors located inside the muscle, in parallel with the main muscle fibers. They respond notably to muscle length and its changes. This afferent activity can contribute, together with other information, to estimating the position and movement of body segments. It does not, however, provide the result directly and unambiguously. The same change in muscle length must indeed be interpreted together with other signals to contribute to this estimate.
More precisely, the spindle response depends on several parameters.
- The speed of the stretch.
- Whether or not the new length is maintained.
- The contraction state of the muscle.
- The activity of gamma motor neurons, which set the sensitivity of the spindle.
- And the recent mechanical history of the muscle.
A rapid stretch, a slow change and a prolonged holding of length therefore do not produce the same afferent response.
In addition, neuromuscular spindles do not form a homogeneous population. Their primary and secondary afferents have distinct morphological and physiological properties. The molecular and developmental determinants of this distinction are only beginning to be characterized (Zampieri & de Nooij, 2021). Primary afferents are classically associated with sensitivity to both length and its rate of change. Secondary afferents, for their part, are associated more with static length information. This distinction nevertheless remains functional and relative. Responses also depend on the state of the spindle, gamma activity and contraction conditions. They therefore do not rest on an absolute opposition between the two types of fibers.
4. Golgi tendon organs
Next, Golgi tendon organs are located at the junction between muscle and tendon. They lie in series with the muscle fibers. They respond to the tensions transmitted in the muscle–tendon complex, notably during muscle contraction. Their activity contributes to the information available on the forces developed. However, it does not on its own constitute a direct and exhaustive measure of the overall force produced by the subject.
Likewise, Golgi tendon organs have their own physiological characteriztics. These characteriztics distinguish their contribution from that of the other proprioceptive receptors (Zampieri & de Nooij, 2021). Their role is often associated with the reflex regulation of muscle tension. Their contribution to the conscious perception of effort remains, on its own, insufficient to account for it. This point will be developed in section 6.
5. Cutaneous and articular information
However, proprioceptive information is not limited to muscle and tendon receptors. The deformations, tensions and displacements of the skin that accompany a segmental movement can provide cues. These relate notably to its direction and amplitude. They thus complement muscle afferents. An experimental study showed that skin stretches produce illusions of movement. These illusions concern the finger, elbow and knee. The effect appears alone or combined with muscle vibration. The cutaneous contribution to kinesthesia is therefore not limited to the joints of the hand (Collins et al., 2005).
Furthermore, articular afferents, arising from joint capsules and ligaments, can contribute to information on the state and movements of the joint. Some responses become particularly marked near the limits of the range of motion. Their contribution is not, however, limited to these positions (Macefield, 2021). A microneurography study of the hand showed that articular afferents have only a limited capacity there. On their own, they encode the direction of movement only partially. This capacity nevertheless seems significant mainly when muscle and tendon afferents cannot contribute to kinesthesia (Burke et al., 1988).
Finally, the most detailed data on the cutaneous and articular contribution to kinesthesia come from targeted studies. These studies concern the finger, wrist, elbow or knee. Their direct transposition to the pelvic support areas and the lumbar region is not established by this work.
6. The sense of effort: a central, not only peripheral, contribution
Indeed, it would be inaccurate to reduce the perception of effort to the activity of Golgi tendon organs. The literature distinguishes two notions. The sensation of force or muscle tension can be partly informed by peripheral afferents. The sense of effort proper is, for its part, associated with the motor command itself (Proske & Gandevia, 2012).
A substantial part of the sense of effort would thus come from a central copy of the motor command sent to the muscles. This copy is sometimes referred to as a corollary discharge. It would therefore come less from afferent feedback from the muscles being used. One study showed that the perception of effort could be associated with markers of the central motor command. It notably revealed a movement-related cortical potential. Finally, this result was obtained during the execution of movements under load and in a state of fatigue (de Morree et al., 2012).
However, this study establishes an association between perception of effort and indices of the central motor command. It does not demonstrate that this perception is produced exclusively by a copy of the motor command. Peripheral feedback from muscles, tendons, joints and skin can also contribute to it. The sense of effort therefore involves a contribution of the central motor command, in interaction with peripheral sensory feedback. The relative share of these contributions depends, for its part, on the task and the context (Proske & Gandevia, 2012).
Ultimately, this distinction matters for this guide. It prevents attributing the perception of postural effort to Golgi tendon organs alone. The chain “Golgi tendon organ → direct perception of effort” is therefore an oversimplification. It ignores the central contribution to this perception. The sense of effort is not, for all that, an exclusively central phenomenon.
7. Information distributed throughout the body
Furthermore, postural control does not draw only on proprioceptive information from the lower limbs. It also integrates information from the trunk, hip and joints. Added to this, beyond proprioceptive afferents strictly speaking, is the vestibular system (Allum et al., 1998).
This distribution across the body thus has a direct consequence for this guide. The proprioception relevant to sitting is not limited to the support of the feet or the joints of the lower limbs. The trunk and hip are sources of proprioceptive information in their own right.
8. Postural corrections are organized on several levels
In particular, proprioceptive information does not all contribute in the same way to triggering and executing a postural correction. A landmark review suggests that proprioceptive information from the trunk and hip may play a particularly important role. This role concerns above all the triggering of balance corrections. Proprioceptive information from the lower limbs would contribute rather to the final shaping of the movement. It would also take part in intermuscular coordination (Allum et al., 1998).
However, this multilevel organization should not be simplified into a strict hierarchy. Rather, it indicates that different proprioceptive sources can contribute differently depending on the phase of the postural response — triggering, then refinement. No single source therefore controls the whole process. This work mainly concerns upright stance and responses to balance perturbations. It does not directly demonstrate the same mechanisms in the sitting position.
9. Application to support changes
In the sitting position, a shift of the pelvis or a change of support simultaneously changes the length of several muscles. These muscles belong notably to the trunk and hip. It also changes the tension transmitted to their tendons. It changes as well the orientation of the joints involved and the associated skin deformations. These changes can alter afferent activity from several sources. They can also provide new cues about the change in body configuration.
Consequently, in the sitting position, information from the trunk and hip may be relevant. It notably makes it possible to track the relationships between the pelvis, the trunk and the support. This application is, however, a mechanistic transposition. The work cited in section 8 does not directly demonstrate the effects of a dynamic support in the sitting position. Controllable support changes can thus modify certain available proprioceptive information. This possibility guarantees neither its effective use by the subject, nor an automatic postural correction, nor a clinical benefit.
10. Key points
- Proprioception relies on muscular, tendinous, articular and cutaneous afferents. To take part in estimating body state and in postural control, this information is integrated with other sources, notably vestibular and visual.
- It is also integrated with internal information linked to the motor command.
- Proprioception and kinesthesia do not refer to two independent systems: the latter refers rather to the conscious dimension of the former.
- The afferent activity of neuromuscular spindles contributes to the information available on muscle length and its changes. That of Golgi tendon organs contributes, for its part, to information on muscle–tendon tensions.
- Neither provides, in isolation, a direct and unambiguous measure of joint position or of the overall force produced.
- Skin and joints also contribute to kinesthesia, in addition to muscle information — with a reservation about transposition to the pelvic support areas.
- The sense of effort involves a contribution of the central motor command, in interaction with peripheral sensory feedback.
- Support changes can modify the available afferent activity, without on their own guaranteeing a postural correction.
In sum, proprioception as described here provides one of the sources of information used by postural control. It adds to the interoceptive information covered in B4 and the tactile information covered in B5. How these different sources are weighted and combined by the nervous system is the subject of B8. How movement itself produces new proprioceptive information is, for its part, the subject of B9.
Scientific references
General framework of proprioception
- Proske, U., & Gandevia, S. C. (2012). The proprioceptive senses: their roles in signaling body shape, body position and movement, and muscle force. Physiological Reviews, 92(4), 1651–1697. https://doi.org/10.1152/physrev.00048.2011
- Proske, U., & Gandevia, S. C. (2009). The kinaesthetic senses. The Journal of Physiology, 587(17), 4139–4146. https://doi.org/10.1113/jphysiol.2009.175372
Neuromuscular spindles and Golgi tendon organs
- Zampieri, N., & de Nooij, J. C. (2021). Regulating muscle spindle and Golgi tendon organ proprioceptor phenotypes. Current Opinion in Physiology, 19, 204–210. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cophys.2020.11.001
Cutaneous and articular contributions
- Macefield, V. G. (2021). The roles of mechanoreceptorsMechanoreceptorsMechanoreceptors are specialized sensory receptors that detect mechanical stimuli (touch, pressure, vibration, stretch) and convert them into nerve signals. This process is called mechanoreception.Read the full entry : Mechanoreceptors in muscle and skin in human proprioception. Current Opinion in Physiology, 21, 48–56. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cophys.2021.03.003
- Collins, D. F., Refshauge, K. M., Todd, G., & Gandevia, S. C. (2005). Cutaneous receptors contribute to kinesthesia at the index finger, elbow, and knee. Journal of Neurophysiology, 94(3), 1699–1706. https://doi.org/10.1152/jn.00191.2005
- Burke, D., Gandevia, S. C., & Macefield, G. (1988). Responses to passive movement of receptors in joint, skin and muscle of the human hand. The Journal of Physiology, 402, 347–361. https://doi.org/10.1113/jphysiol.1988.sp017208
Sense of effort and central motor command
- de Morree, H. M., Klein, C., & Marcora, S. M. (2012). Perception of effort reflects central motor command during movement execution. Psychophysiology, 49(9), 1242–1253. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1469-8986.2012.01399.x
Proprioceptive contribution of the trunk and hip and postural control
- Allum, J. H. J., Bloem, B. R., Carpenter, M. G., Hulliger, M., & Hadders-Algra, M. (1998). Proprioceptive control of posture: a review of new concepts. Gait & Posture, 8(3), 214–242. https://doi.org/10.1016/S0966-6362(98)00027-7
