1. A thesis to clarify from the outset: transformation, not extinction
First, it would be inaccurate to claim that prolonged, unvarying holding eventually “switches off” afferent signals or makes the body insensitive. Sensory adaptation, observed in all sensory systems, is better understood as a change in coding strategy. A nervous system that receives a stimulus whose statistical properties vary little adjusts the way it encodes that stimulus. It thus continues to encode it rather than ceasing to encode it (Wark et al., 2007).
Consequently, one should avoid writing that the body “stops perceiving” sustained support. The correct formulation is more nuanced: the response of certain receptor populations can decrease under stable stimulation. Others, by contrast, continue to encode part of it. The information available thus changes in composition rather than disappearing. The following sections develop this transformation at several levels: peripheral (receptor adaptation), central (cortical processing), integrative (reweighting), behavioral (active exploration and the need to move) and nociceptive (sensitization).
2. Adaptation of cutaneous afferents under sustained stimulation
When a mechanical stimulus varies little, some afferents respond mainly to transitions. Others, by contrast, maintain activity during the stable phase. The amplitude and timing of this response, however, depend on the type of afferent, the nature of the stimulus, its intensity, its duration and the body region studied. Consequently, results obtained on the glabrous skin of the hand cannot be transposed directly to the support areas in sitting.
For example, work on the vibratory adaptation of cutaneous afferents illustrates this heterogeneity. Response thresholds rise and then fall with time constants that vary with fiber type. Thus, slowly adapting type I afferents adapt fastest and Pacinian afferents slowest. Rapidly adapting afferents show an intermediate profile. In addition, recovery after adaptation follows its own time course. This differs for each fiber type (Bensmaïa et al., 2005 ; Leung et al., 2005). Stable pressure, indentation and prolonged vibration therefore do not produce interchangeable adaptations. They are indeed distinct stimuli, each with its own dynamics of adaptation and recovery.
3. Peripheral adaptation, central processing and perception
Furthermore, adaptation can occur at several levels of the nervous system. It can involve the receptor, the afferent fiber, the spinal cord or subcortical relays. It can also involve the somatosensory cortex, up to conscious perception and behavior. A decrease in the peripheral response therefore does not necessarily mean that sensory experience decreases in the same proportion.
For example, a functional imaging study examined sustained pressure stimulation on the fingertip. It shows a gradual decrease in activity in several somatosensory cortical regions. It also shows a change in their functional connectivity over the course of the stimulation (Chung et al., 2015). This observation must be interpreted with caution: it concerns pressure applied to the fingertip for fifteen seconds in healthy volunteers. By contrast, it concerns neither a prolonged sitting posture nor the pelvic support areas. It nevertheless illustrates that cortical adaptation should not be equated with simple exhaustion of the system: it may correspond to a change in how efficiently information that has become predictable is processed, without the representation of the contact state disappearing.
4. Low postural variation and the dynamic component of proprioception
In addition, the afferents of neuromuscular spindles, presented in B3, have pronounced dynamic sensitivity. They respond strongly to the speed at which a muscle is stretched, beyond their response to the held length itself. Recordings in humans confirm that this dynamic component largely dominates the response of primary afferents to stretch, while the static component linked solely to held length is comparatively weaker and more variable from one afferent to another (Edin & Vallbo, 1990).
When muscle lengths and their rates of change vary little, the dynamic components associated with these changes are less engaged. However, information about the state of the muscle may nevertheless persist. These data do not make it possible to establish directly how proprioceptive activity evolves during prolonged sitting. Indeed, the reference used concerns neither this task nor the muscles involved in seated support.
5. Low variability and reweighting
Furthermore, B8 showed that the relative contribution of sensory information can change when its usability changes. The prolonged holding described in the previous sections modifies certain afferent responses and reduces the frequency of certain sensory events. However, it would be excessive to automatically infer reweighting from this. Information that varies little is not necessarily less reliable. Moreover, the work of Assländer and Peterka mainly concerns experimental perturbations in standing (Assländer & Peterka, 2014).
The possibility that prolonged adaptation indirectly changes the contribution of certain information to the postural estimate is therefore a research hypothesis. It is not a demonstrated consequence for the sitting position.
6. Fewer opportunities for sensory renewal
In addition, B9 showed that movement can change sampling conditions and produce, renew or refine certain sensory information. Low-variability holding involves fewer changes of support and configuration likely to renew this information. It does not, however, make it possible to determine whether the missing movements would have had a specifically exploratory function.
This reduction is thus a behavioral dimension of the transformation discussed in this chapter. It is distinct from the receptor adaptation described in sections 2 to 4. Indeed, receptors respond differently to an unchanged stimulus. In addition, the subject less often produces the movements that would renew that stimulus. The two dimensions combine, without one being reducible to the other.
7. The need to move: a multifactorial response
However, the need to change position during prolonged sitting is sometimes interpreted as a direct sign of sensory adaptation. This interpretation is too narrow. B4 has already established that discomfort cannot be reduced to pain; in the same way, the need to move can be influenced by factors largely independent of the adaptation described in this chapter. These may include muscle fatigue, warmth or a feeling of compression. They may also include stiffness, attention, habit, the task at hand, expectations, nociceptive activity, temperature, emotional state or duration of exposure.
Consequently, an isolated behavioral observation — a change of position — does not make it possible to identify the exact contribution of sensory adaptation among all these factors. A change of position more likely combines several mechanisms at once than isolates a single one.
8. Nociception and sensitization over time
Furthermore, B10 established the distinction between nociception and pain. It also showed that peripheral or central sensitizationCentral sensitizationCentral sensitization refers to an amplification of the central nervous system's response to sensory signals: pain can then be more intense, more widespread or longer-lasting than the state of the tissues would suggest.Read the full entry : Central sensitization can change the relationship between a stimulus and its associated nociceptive activity. The duration, intensity and location of loads and the state of the tissues can take part in the conditions likely to activate or sensitize nociceptors. However, prolonged holding does not support the conclusion either that peripheral or central sensitization has occurred or that a given nociceptive activity will lead to pain. Nor does the absence of identifiable damage, on its own, establish or rule out a change in nociceptive processing.
9. The limits of static pressure mapping
First, a pressure map taken at a given moment describes a mechanical distribution at the interface. It does not directly show whether mechanoreceptorsMechanoreceptorsMechanoreceptors are specialized sensory receptors that detect mechanical stimuli (touch, pressure, vibration, stretch) and convert them into nerve signals. This process is called mechanoreception.Read the full entry : Mechanoreceptors have adapted or whether sensation has decreased. Nor does it indicate whether the subject remains attentive to the contact or whether discomfort is developing. Finally, it does not show whether a need to move is linked to that specific area or whether the deep tissues show any particular change. This principle has been established since B2 and recalled several times in this sub-guide.
By contrast, to analyze repetition and stillness, one must examine the dynamics rather than the snapshot. The analysis covers changes over time, the frequency of shifts and the duration of plateaus. It also covers load transfers, the amplitude of variations and the subject’s subjective response. Moreover, a mechanical measurement does not replace how things feel. A stable pressure can remain mechanically unchanged while the subjective experience evolves. Conversely, a change in pressure can be measured without being clearly perceived. These data describe different levels, which must be interpreted together rather than in isolation.
10. Application to sitting and the SBNFA™ framework
More precisely, this chapter sheds light on a distinction already made in the Organization in Permanent Flows sub-guide. It links it to sensory physiology. This distinction contrasts static sitting — a held, low-variability configuration that cannot be sustained over time — with Aporia® stable dynamic sitting. The latter offers a plurality of equilibrium configurations within a cone of stability, without imposing movement on the subject. Indeed, a configuration held with few changes of support reduces the temporal diversity of certain mechanical stimuli and the opportunities to renew contacts. The available data do not, however, make it possible to directly quantify the sensory adaptation produced in the different support areas in the sitting position.
By contrast, stable dynamic sitting preserves the independent mobility of the right and left hips and, when the feet take part in support, of the right and left ankles. Conversely, a seat becomes unstable when it immobilizes or locks together these regulators and prevents their differentiated adjustments. This criterion is distinct from the mere presence or absence of movement of the support. Stable dynamic sitting thus offers several accessible equilibrium configurations within a cone of stability, without imposing constant movement. It thereby makes it possible to renew support and sensory conditions. This possibility guarantees neither its actual use nor a systematic improvement in comfort, bodily perception or pain.
12. Key points
- Prolonged, unvarying holding transforms the sensory information available; it does not switch it off.
- Cutaneous afferents show distinct adaptation and recovery dynamics depending on their type; data obtained on the glabrous skin of the hand do not transpose directly to the support areas in sitting.
- Adaptation can occur at several levels — receptor, spinal cord, cortex, perception — and a peripheral decrease does not mean a proportional decrease in experience.
- When muscle lengths and their rates of change vary little, the dynamic components associated with these changes are less engaged; information about the state of the muscle may nevertheless persist.
- Reweighting in the sense of B8 cannot be automatically inferred from low variability: this possibility remains a research hypothesis, not a demonstrated consequence in the sitting position.
- Prolonged holding reduces the configuration changes likely to renew certain information; it does not establish that the missing movements would have had a specifically exploratory function.
- The need to move remains multifactorial; it cannot be attributed in isolation to sensory adaptation.
- Duration and low variability add to the parameters already identified in B10 as relevant to nociceptive sensitization, without making it possible to predict it for a given user.
- A static pressure map provides no information on sensory adaptation or on subjective experience: only the analysis of its dynamics over time, cross-checked with reported experience, allows a cautious interpretation.
A multifactorial transformation over time
In sum, this chapter relates several processes presented in the Sensory Flows sub-guide. It links receptor adaptation (B2, B3, B5), reliability-based reweighting (B8), active exploration (B9) and nociception (B10) around a single situation: prolonged holding of a low-variability posture. None of these mechanisms works in isolation; it is their combination that characterizes how sensory information is transformed over time, without ever being switched off.
Scientific references
Sensory adaptation
- Wark, B., Lundstrom, B. N., & Fairhall, A. (2007). Sensory adaptation. Current Opinion in Neurobiology, 17(4), 423–429. PMID: 17714934.
- Bensmaïa, S. J., Leung, Y. Y., Hsiao, S. S., & Johnson, K. O. (2005). Vibratory adaptation of cutaneous mechanoreceptive afferents. Journal of Neurophysiology, 94(5), 3023–3036. PMID: 16014802.
- Leung, Y. Y., Bensmaïa, S. J., Hsiao, S. S., & Johnson, K. O. (2005). Time-course of vibratory adaptation and recovery in cutaneous mechanoreceptive afferents. Journal of Neurophysiology, 94(5), 3037–3045. PMID: 16222071.
- Chung, Y. G., Han, S. W., Kim, H. S., et al. (2015). Adaptation of cortical activity to sustained pressure stimulation on the fingertip. BMC Neuroscience, 16, 71. PMID: 26514637.
Proprioception and postural control
- Edin, B. B., & Vallbo, Å. B. (1990). Dynamic response of human muscle spindle afferents to stretch. Journal of Neurophysiology, 63(6), 1297–1306. PMID: 2141632.
- Assländer, L., & Peterka, R. J. (2014). Sensory reweighting dynamics in human postural controlPostural controlPostural control is the function by which the nervous system controls the body’s position in space, with two objectives: orientation of body segments relative to one another and to the environment, and balance.Read the full entry : Postural control. Journal of Neurophysiology, 111(9), 1852–1864. PMID: 24501263.
